"In this sticky web that we're all in, behaving decently is no small task." -- Novelist Stacey D'Erasmo

Saturday, October 30, 2021

For Women Only

      I recently attended a book festival where I heard author Maya Shanbhag Lang talk about her book and her life -- her pregnancy, her daughter, her mother and her mother's journey into Alzheimer's. The book is a memoir called What We Carry, and I recommend it to all women, especially women who are around our age.

     I usually don't recommend books. For one thing, most people aren't interested in books -- or at least not interested enough to read them. According to the Department of Education fewer than half of Americans adults are proficient at reading. A quarter of Americans admit to never reading a book. Many others say they read or listen to just one book a year. The average book reader gets through four books per year. But the average is skewed by a few avid readers -- mostly college-educated women -- who go through a few dozen per year.

     I guess I'm a pretty avid reader. But honestly, most of the books I pick up are not academic tomes or serious literature. I gravitate toward mysteries from people like Michael Connelly and Robert Crais . . . and yeah, I admit it, I have gone through Sue Grafton from A is for Alibi to Y is for Yesterday

     Sometimes I read history (like The Splendid and the Vile by Erik Larson), but my latest finds are George Pelecanos, who sets his stories in Washington, DC, and Stephen Mack Jones who prowls the streets of Detroit.

     So reading Maya Shanbhag Lang was a stretch for me. It's a memoir mostly about her mother, a doctor who immigrated from India.

     To be honest, I didn't much like the first half of the book. The author drones on, charging her father with abuse, complaining about her mother's neglect, moaning about her depression.

     But then her mother starts to develop Alzheimer's. About halfway through the book the mother moves in with Maya and her husband and young daughter. That's when Maya begins to unravel the myths and false stories of her mother's life, and gets to know the real person with all her strengths and frailties.

     Eventually Maya and her brother (who doesn't do much to help) decide to put their mother into an assisted-living facility. This changes things yet again. Maya finally accepts who her mother really is and begins to appreciate all her mother has done. Maya struggles to understand the idea of home, the reality of love, the tension between self care and caring for others. This new relationship also influences how Maya sees her own daughter and affects her emotional reaction to the demands of motherhood.

     Like I said, most men will probably not be interested in the complexities and emotional ups and downs of this mother/daughter relationship. But I think a lot of women will identify with her journey. If I'm wrong, in my next post about books I'll gun for mysteries which, by all evidence, are more closely handcuffed to my own guilty pleasures.

23 comments:

Rian said...

Tom, I just ordered a sample of "what we carry" for my kindle reader. I'm interested as my mom and both my aunts had Alzheimer's. but I will say that this is not the type of book I usually read. I did read "Still Alice" and "Losing my Mind" (books about Alzheimer's) a while back. But generally I read mysteries (nothing gory, just light or cozy)... and I do like small town cozies like The Midford Series... and Irish trilogies... usually fiction. Non-fiction and memoirs although interesting are usually depressing. Some old books that were my favorites were The Outlander series, Galway Bay, and Lady of Hay. But I read daily... almost every afternoon and every night. Absolutely love books (prefer real to e-readers, but will take either).

Celia said...

Going to think about your book review for awhile. I have a sister who was recently diagnosed with Alzheimers and then the diagnois was recinded for "age related dementia." Is that better? Time will tell.

Meanwhile I love Robert Crais, and dreadfully miss Sue Grafton. I'm still reading both fiction and biographies of those who lived through Vietnam,"The Things They Carried" by Tim O'Brien is remarkable. Many my age are still marked by that war. Books and film are keeping me sane and happy while our area is still hiding out from the plague (very high risk here). My current book is a biography "Maria Mahoi of the Islands" of a Hawaiian woman who lived out her life in the small islands of the coast of Vancouver Island in British Columbia. I had no idea there was an Hawaiian expat community there. Hope I can keep reading forver.

Barb said...

I now have two new authors took up, thanks! And I will think on of this book is for me. I've absutely refused to read Still Alice.

Kay said...

My 92 year old mother is healthy as can be, but starting to get forgetful which has its worrisome moments. This sounds like an interesting book. Not quite the sort I'm into though.

Kevin from Virginia said...

Tom, two recommendations: James Salter and Tom McGuane. Libraries are full of their books and every one is elegant, stirring and telling.

Miss Merry said...

Original Sue Grafton reader. Disappointed we didn't make it to Z. I met her in person during an author luncheon in the 1980's, sponsored by the Cleveland Plain Dealer. We also recently lost another one of my favorites who wrote in a similar style- Margaret Maron. These days I mostly read cozy mysteries with an occasional biography. I am a member of the party that skews the numbers. I always have a book reading in progress. I probably read 5-10 books a month. I don't mind re-reading a series when a new book is published.

Gail, northern California said...

I'm currently reading "A Gentleman in Moscow". Each evening I look forward to another chapter, wondering "what is Count Rostov up to now?" I don't want to read a book that makes me sad. There's enough sorrow in my life without adding more. Escapism? So be it.

Tom said...

Kevin, thanks for the recommendations. Gail -- I read Gentleman last year ... loved it. He's got a new one out, The Lincoln Highway. I have it on order at my library.

Hope Springs said...

So I guess I'd be an avid reader then. And I generally love memoir. Thanks for the recommendation. Definitely looking it up.

Tabor said...

Sounds like a good book. So many books to read.

Janette said...

Thank you for the recommend. We don’t seem to have Alzheimer’s in our family and I am past reading about the childhood abuse of successful people. I don’t think I could get past the beginning of the book. Maybe I can just read the second half? . I dropped “the poor me” list about ten years ago. I tire of this generation who trash their parents who give them the leg up to succeed.
I am a “small reader”-about 35 books a year. I did not learn how to read until high school- which helps me to excuse my poor writing ability.
Currently, I am rereading my high school book list. Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee, 1984, Slaughter House Five, Jane Eyre. I have a shelf. My oldest grand goes to high school next year. I am excited about reading HIS book list. He just finished I am Number Four.
My husband and his brother, our son and son in law each read about 100 books a year. McCraffery, Flynn/Mills, Childs, Greaney, Jeff Carson, Krueger, dystopian, future fiction, military, leadership head their lists.Add Scientific journals for the younger men. Our daughter and daughter in law tend to read book club (30 or so a year) and whatever their younger children are reading (Full of belly laughs with Dogman and Captain Underpants). They will be back to industry books in a few years.
It is enjoyable at Christmas to have everyone reading their newest book at the same time!
It would be interesting to hear which authors were life changing for people. Buscaglia, KublerRoss, Hawthorne and Lewis head my list.

Gail, northern California said...

Some delightful animation by Delphine Burrus on "Gentleman" Towles' website:
https://www.amortowles.com/a-gentleman-in-moscow-about-the-book/

Jennifer (UnfoldAndBegin) said...

My sister and I were ones that used to skew the numbers. I know I was reading anywhere from 2 to 3 books a week, and 3 was a minimum for her. My love of reading began with her and after she died, I went a full year before reading a book again. Back in the day, we used to keep small notebooks of the authors and books we read. We had to take them to the library with us to make sure we weren't borrowing something we already read. We loved mysteries and suspense and went through all the Doyle, Christie, Holt, and Whitney novels. Then we found Anne Perry and her Pitt and Monk series. And several other series authors. Now I read cozy mysteries because they're quick to read. I have to admit it's now hard to surprise me with mysteries. The last one that did was The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo. While I knew who did it, I was vastly wrong as to the why!

Wisewebwoman said...

I am re-reading "Being Mortal" Tom and something tells me you would enjoy it. It is anecdotal and fascinating on the process of aging. You may have read it.

I have guilty pleasures in reading too. But why on earth do we say guilty? WE should be unapologetic about it. A great sorbet for the brain, cleansing the palate of the heavier stuff.

XO
WWW

Carol Cassara said...

This is definitely a tome I'd be interested in reading.

Mage said...

I'll read this from the library. The back half.....

Rita said...

Congratulations on trying something new. You're terrific.

Rebecca Olkowski said...

I get sent quite a lot of books because of my blog but most just sit there. I don't have enough time or a comfortable place to sit and am addicted to streaming TV. I'd say most of them are sub-par. Occasionally, I get a good one I can help promote. I like supporting midlife plus authors but don't have the patience for badly written books.

Anonymous said...

No one ever asked, but I "peruse" between 80 to 100 books a year and finish about 70 or so. Greatful for libraries. Now, add on reading periodicals, blogs, etc... No kindle , no audiobooks.

Linda Myers said...

I read out loud to my husband Art most nights before we sleep. "Gentleman" was a special pleasure. Just now I put "Lincoln Highway" on reserve at my library. We're in Tucson now for the winter, but I order ebooks from my Seattle library.

Barbara said...

I love Linda's comment that she reads to her husband each night. I always thought that would be a wonderful way to share. I go through a lot of books. I say it that way because many are books on tape and most of the hard books are non-fiction. I love books. I love learning about something, someone or someplace new. Mother/daughter relationships can be very messy and/or very sweet. Sounds like a good book.

SmartOoo said...

Most beneficial gentleman speeches and toasts are made to enliven supply accolade up to the wedding couple. Newbie audio system the attention of loud crowds should always think about typically the great norm off presentation, which is their private. best man speaches
Read More: German shepherd husky mix

Aaron Jeremy said...

CHIEF DR LUCKY HERBAL THERAPY
Thank you very much for curing my Human Papillomavirus (HPV) totally. You are really a Godsent, I promise you that I will always recommend you. and to share your testimony to people. Contact him now thanks all.
CHIEF DR LUCKY HERBAL THERAPY CAN AS WELL CURE THE FOLLOWING VIRUSES :-
1: HIV/AIDS
2: HSV
3: LUPUS
4: ALS
5: HEPATITIS B
6: DIABETES
7: HUMAN PAPILLOMAVIRUS (HPV)
8: CANCER
9: PAD
10: PENIS ENLARGEMENT
11: THYROID ETC..

WhatsApp him on +2348132777335 or email (chiefdrlucky@gmail.com).

Http://facebook.com/chiefdrlucky